PARENTHOOD: Namaste No More - Give Me My Remote : Give Me My Remote

PARENTHOOD: Namaste No More

May 10, 2010 by  

In a culture consumed with immediate gratification, we rarely think about the long-term consequences of our decisions. Whether you feast on the laughter elicited by an off-color joke, the bliss of ignoring financial hardships, or the warm affection of a new love, it is easy to ignore the consequences of building a legacy. Multiply these factors by the number of people in a large family, and there is no wonder we find so many ways to avoid eating dinner together!

In sticking with Parenthood’s mission to explore the family unit on all fronts, this week’s episode raised life altering questions for all three generations. This was tough to watch, but in the best way possible. This was not my favorite episode of the season, but I think it was the most powerful.

Bonnie Bedelia OWNED this hour of television. The term, “gravitas,” seems to have been retired in TV and film criticism, brought out of its shell only if Morgan Freeman is onscreen. It is time to revisit that practice and give Ms. Bedelia her due. As the matriarch of the Braverman clan, Camille was crushed by the weight of Zeke’s lies. As she glared across the table, waiting for her husband to come clean about their economic woes, I was captivated. Bedelia could teach a master class on nonverbal communication. The aftermath, informing Sarah about the “woman up north,” was noteworthy for being so simple. Without a teary build or wild gesticulations, a distinguished actress showed the audience what real life looks and feels like.

The dinner scene was absolutely brutal. Watching a family’s foundation implode is not a pretty sight. Wasn’t it touching, though, to see four siblings come together to protect their mother? Their intentions were not to embarrass their father, only to show that they were old enough to make adult decisions. Were it not for Dax Shepard’s amusing struggle to turn scripted lines into authentic sentiments, this story would have played out without a single laugh. Yet, I would not have changed a thing about it.

Lauren Graham is not playing the most responsible mother on TV, but she may be the most believable daughter. Sarah’s need for approval from her family, even as her age changes census brackets, fits her circumstances. Her siblings are succeeding in their work, and raising families with their partners. After jousting with her mother all season, especially after finding damning evidence of her father’s infidelity, Sarah rose to the occasion when the chips were down. By reaching out to Camille, then sharing the PhotoShop project that framed the Bravermans in the most positive light, the first daughter was the best child.

My biggest gripe with this episode is the angst surrounding Haddie, Amber, and Steve. Raising the topic of “the V card” is fair game, particularly for a 10pm primetime show. For me, the miscalculation was assuming that viewers thought of Haddie and Amber as particularly close friends. Before their brief conversation in this episode, I never saw them as confidants. Since they rarely share scenes, it was too soon to place a boy between them. Steve is ultimately irrelevant, both as a character and a symbol. The fights that will emerge from his courtship of Amber, however, would be more believable if the story had played out over a longer period of time.

Though I was not on board with the pacing of the story, I must acknowledge Sarah Ramos’ performance as Haddie. Every beat of Haddie’s story over the past few weeks, whether pestering Adam to let her date or dealing with Kristina over her mail-order bra, have felt like a young woman trying to grow up. When confronted with the very adult expectations of her hormonal boyfriend, Haddie reminded us why she is a smart and responsible girl. Rebuffing Steve’s advances by saying, “I’m not going to, like, ripen…like a piece of fruit,” Haddie lived up to her parents’ expectations to do the right thing. Unfortunately for Adam & Kristina, it would be out of character for their daughter to TELL them about it.

Finally, my TV girlfriend Erika Christensen put a brave face behind the “Victory is about having fun” message for ten minutes, before Racquel stirred her competitive spirit. I fully endorse Jabbar’s participation on the team, since we may see Jasmine and Julia get a chance to spend time together. Their approaches to life are vastly different, and that could lead to some very entertaining moments.

Before I turn the conversation over to you, a quick musical note. The closing song of the episode, “Live Forever,” was a perfect companion piece of Sarah’s class project, and was performed by Drew Holcomb & The Neighbors. You can find the song on iTunes or wherever you illegally download music.

Comments

6 Responses to “PARENTHOOD: Namaste No More”

  1. Todd on May 10th, 2010 1:50 pm

    I agree with your review 99.5%. The only thing we disagree on is Haddie and Amber, They’re cousins, so I wouldn’t go right to thinking that they are BFF’s but they have that family connection. I can picture how this will play out, possibly causing a rift between Sarah and Adam.

  2. Nicole on May 10th, 2010 4:06 pm

    I agree wholeheartedly with your review Erik, except I will say that I didn’t have as a big a problem as you accepting that Haddie and Amber have a strong enough friendship to warrant the drama that is no doubt around the corner for both of them. We’ve seen a few scenes of Haddie going to Amber for advice, and of the two girls hanging out together. Since we aren’t with them all day long, the scenes that they’ve shown have been sufficient to plant the notion of a burgeoning friendship in my mind. And don’t forget – at that age, someone you’ve been friends with only for a brief period can still cause huge emotional turmoil. Not to mention the fact that I actaully prefer that they aren’t BEST friends, or the idea of Amber dating Steve would kind of make me hate Amber, and I really really like her and don’t want that to change. I crack up whenever I see her because all I can think is “Her?” and “Egg” but she’s killing it on this show and although I can’t help but think of Arrested Development, she’s playing such a completely different character here, she hardly even looks the same.

  3. Kary on May 10th, 2010 5:44 pm

    I love this recap. I agree about the dinner and B.Bedelia. The dinner was pretty intense and so “true”. and I like that there is no “showy” acting. Everything is so underplayed and real. The scene with the 4 siblings in the car was hoot. More scenes with them together, please.

  4. Erik on May 10th, 2010 5:59 pm

    Todd: Both you and Nicole poked very reasonable holes in my Haddie/Amber argument. There are a lot of moving parts in Parenthood, so it was probably unfair of me to limit the significance of their friendship to onscreen bonding time.

    I LOVE your prognostication about Sarah & Adam butting heads over the Steve situation. As the oldest of the Braverman brood, I completely buy the idea that they have battled furiously over far more minor issues. With the well-being of their daughters at stake, Lauren Graham & Peter Krause should be amped up for a big confrontation.

    Which of the sibling stories is your favorite thus far?

  5. Erik on May 10th, 2010 6:05 pm

    Nicole: I defer to your judgment on the Haddie/Amber dynamic. You and Todd took the long view of how to contextualize their friendship, and I probably spoke too soon. It’s possible I was still thinking about how to overwrite that section of my House review about “third wheels.” 🙂

    Mae Whitman is serving her character with experience and range. In the hands of a less seasoned performer, I think Amber could have been pigeonholed as the black sheep of the family. It’s amazing that Ann from AD and the little girl from Hope Floats is playing a tough young woman. Whitman’s IMDB page reads like an almanac of television and film from 1994-2009. There has to be a reason why she keeps booking new jobs, and we are seeing it every week on Parenthood.

  6. Erik on May 10th, 2010 6:10 pm

    Kary: Thanks for joining the discussion! I apologize for not getting the recap finished sooner, but the dinner scene truly jarred me. It was difficult to summarize a scene that is almost indescribable. The tension at the table was almost too difficult to watch. We’ve all had those difficult moments, whether it be with family, friends, or other loved ones. Those raw emotions you noted were in sharp contrast with the playful laughs and fairytale endings that we expect from family programs.

    I hope the writers keep putting all 4 siblings in the same room, and I look forward to reading your thoughts on this week’s new episode!