Favorite Television Episodes of the 2010s

What we said then:: “These episodes are never ranked, but if I had to pick my top hour of the year, I'd make a strong, strong case for "Bad Blood."

SLEEPY HOLLOW has always worked best when the entire team is there, fighting against their common enemies, and season 1 established the "ultimate collection of underdogs"…but, unfortunately for them, they discovered in the final moments of the season 1 finale that they had a traitor in the group: Henry, was actually Jeremy, Ichabod and Katrina's presumed-dead son. Oh, and he was War, a horseman of the apocalypse.

The final 5 minutes of the episode -- as Henry laid out to his captured parents how wholly he had deceived his father (and the audience), while Abbie was in purgatory, getting back the pieces of her memory which filled in the blanks for her -- is my favorite thing the show has done so far, as the very real danger Abbie was in was juxtaposed with how fantastically the writers had pulled a delicious long-con on everyone. (At this point, I've watched the end sequence probably 10 times between covering events, etc., and I still get chills every time I see it. John Noble (Henry), Tom Mison (Ichabod), Nicole Beharie (Abbie), and Katia Winter (Katrina) are all sofreaking good.) It set the bar high for what SLEEPY HOLLOW can do, and I look forward to the next time the show can throw me so completely.”

(CR: Brownie Harris/FOX)